The Table Decorating Results are In!

I know you’re dying to hear the results of the table decorating competition from the state fair so I’ll just cut to the chase: I didn’t win. But I never even expected to come in first place so yeah – no biggie. (Oh yeah, I also didn’t get second or third).

Nonetheless, there’s my table, with the crowds clamoring to see it.

IMG_5303

Let’s talk about the judging. As a teacher, I know that I can only expect my students to complete an assignment to my specifications if I make those specifications explicitly clear. The first thing I got dinged on was that my theme was not written on the top of my menu. Well I read the four pages of “table decorating rules” and not once did it say to clearly proclaim your obvious theme onto your menu. I noticed that several other people did the same thing wrong…hence the “Dutch Breakfast?” at the top of my critique.

Need a closer look –  here ya go:

IMG_5302

An ivory tablecloth! Who knew?! Also, I had no clue that I literally had to put “water” as one of my beverages. Notice that I at least got points for my “research and creativity.”

Now I know you’re dying to know what the winning table looked like (note: when setting up, this woman refused to have her table next to mine, so I already pretty much hated her):

IMG_5304

She also had some sort of narrative to go along with her table that described what eating her dessert by the fire would be like, and while I thought the duck was overkill, the judging clearly thought it was “charming.”

We perused all of the tables with a new level of understanding, and were surprised to see that some of the tables we thought had a dated aesthetic (Courtney called it “Shilo Inn circa 1987”), they received some of the better critiques. Although I didn’t win, we heard a woman squeal, “I’ve always wanted to do this!” when looking at our tables, so clearly I’m living the dream.

The big question now is would I do this again? On one hand, I’m like no no no no no. It was a lot more expensive than I expected to purchase all these little items, and a lot of time and effort (not to mention that I will have to take a half day off this week just to go pick up my stuff!). Then on the flip side, now that I’ve seen what I did wrong, I want to do it right. Courtney and I joked that next year my menu should literally be titled, “Shilo Inn circa 1987” (look for lots of shells, sand, and pastel wicker). Also, now that I know how to do it, I have an whole YEAR to plan the most intensely amazing table that judge has ever seen.

For now, I’m exhausted, but ask me again in June and we’ll see…

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s